Looking for COVID-19 Resources? Bridge is here to help!
Blog
Back to Blog

Unvetted Job Descriptions Plague Chaotic Immigration Programs 

Bridge Team Member

Building a consistent immigration program can feel like an insurmountable challenge. Instead of worrying about the endgame, your recruiters, hiring managers, and People team are better off working toward an emerging program. Small improvements over time make a significant difference.

You can take steps in the coming weeks to better manage your talent, including international applicants and employees. That includes taking a hard look at how your team members craft job descriptions.

 

Your Job Descriptions Can Hold Your Immigration Program Back

Job descriptions seem simple enough, but in reality, they might kick off a messy immigration workflow. Once an international candidate applies for a position, your team has to be ready to evaluate their potential and consider the immigration implications.

Are the position and applicant eligible for an employment-based visa and, if so, what are your stakeholders’ next steps?

Job descriptions can be inconsistent

You may not have taken steps to standardize job descriptions based on immigration regulations and a clear internal policy yet. Unfortunately, this means your team writes a new job description each time a position opens up, and it’s a toss-up whether it’ll be ready for the immigration application process.

Job descriptions can foster confusion

A hallmark feature of a chaotic immigration program is confusion among the internal stakeholders regarding:

  • Which open positions are appropriate for international employees based on the responsibilities and U.S. immigration regulations, and
  • When international applicants are eligible for an employment-based visa.

Companies that struggle to keep up with changing immigration regulations often fail to have a defined immigration policy. In turn, the job descriptions lack clarity regarding whether international workers should apply. 

International workers who throw their hats in the ring might end up corresponding with hiring managers or People team members who aren’t sure about sponsorship. Ineligible candidates may get further along in the process than they should. It’s a vicious cycle of uncertainty.

Job descriptions can waste time and monetary resources

When applying for an employment-based immigration visa, federal agencies evaluate whether the international employee should fill the position and not someone currently residing in the country.

For example, H1-B visas are based on specialty occupations. The job description must outline a specialty occupation per the regulations. Then, the international applicant’s education, training, and experience must fulfill that specialty role.

Because of the complexity of immigration rules, it’s helpful to work with immigration counsel to craft job descriptions that outline the minimum education and training requirements and job responsibilities, focusing on the specific, technical aspects of the role—not “soft skills.”

In a chaotic immigration program, your team may have to rewrite the description for the application process after finding a candidate based on the initial job ad. This wastes time and your People team’s efforts.

Job descriptions can increase the risk of RFEs and Audits

Poorly written or rewritten job descriptions can increase the risk of Requests for Evidence (RFEs).

For instance, if your team doesn’t fully understand U.S. immigration regulations and enforcement due to recent changes or inexperience, they may submit a suboptimal description. If they hope to secure an H1-B visa, but the job description doesn’t properly demonstrate a specialty occupation, you can expect an RFE for additional proof. 

Discrepancies between the role and the applicant can lead to RFEs, as well. If your team had to rewrite the job description for the application process, you might find your international candidate isn’t ideal for the role. Though they may fit based on the initial job description, their education, training, and experience may not align with the new, immigration-vetted description.

Another problem is if you’ve applied different hiring requirements to the same or similar positions over time. The DOL or USCIS may become concerned with your company’s inconsistencies, and one may audit your immigration program.

 

Strive for “Immigration-Ready” Job Descriptions

The job descriptions you use for recruiting should be ready for the immigration application process.

When you craft an optimal job description the first time around, you’ll get high-quality candidates. Then, if your business selects an international applicant, your People team is ready to jump into the immigration journey.

Your team can move forward by:

  • Defining which positions are eligible for sponsorship: Not all jobs are appropriate for an employment-based visa, which is why role standardization is necessary. If you haven’t already, define which roles you can fill with international employees and which you can’t. Your internal stakeholders benefit from a clear policy.
  • Reviewing immigration application requirements: To understand what makes a job description immigration-ready, analyze the U.S. Department of Labor certification requirements (for H-1B, H-2A, and H-2B) and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services visa requirements. This review gives your team a chance to catch up on changes made under the current administration and can be immensely helpful for the less experienced members of your team.
  • Connecting with immigration counsel: When beginning to craft immigration-ready job descriptions, it’s best to partner with someone experienced. Writing job descriptions for positions eligible for a visa is a skill your team has to learn and improve over time.
  • Crafting consistent, immigration-ready job descriptions: Finally, your team can apply what it’s learned. It can start by writing consistent, immigration-ready job descriptions for your most frequently sponsored positions.

 

Start to Consider an Immigration Provider

Depending on your organization’s journey toward building a predictable immigration program, you may not be ready to invest in a comprehensive immigration vendor. Instead, you may continue to rely on email and ad hoc technology tools.

While these are enough to begin improving your role standardization, it’s time to contemplate what you’d need from an immigration vendor. Research your options. The right provider acts as a strategic partner in standardizing the roles available to international employees and crafting immigration-ready job descriptions.

Content in this publication is not intended as legal advice, nor should it be relied on as such. For additional information on the issues discussed, consult a Bridge-affiliated partner attorney or another qualified legal professional.

Tags:

More from the Blog

Elevate Your Immigration Process with a Strategic Approach

Once the data is clean and uploaded, the main business users are trained, and the policies are established; immigration turns from an administrative burden into a strategic business endeavor. By unlocking a more holistic People analytics & insights, Talent leaders can arm business leaders to make informed decisions that are not only good for the organization, but also the community and for its people. 

Read Story

A Better Way to Track International Employee Data in 2021 and Beyond

Modern companies require modern access to data and insights, the days of using spreadsheets (not systems) and ad-hoc reporting requests (not on-demand) are being phased out. In the People Operations world, there are very few situations that are static and slow-moving, so shouldn't your data be able to keep up with the pace of your business. But before you throw your old system in the bin, consider what key metrics would be critical to have visibility into and also what sort of vendor can help you best access the data and automated processes that you need.

Read Story

Key Immigration Data Points That People Teams Should be Tracking

Once companies choose to engage with visa sponsorship for their workforce, they also inherit more process, vendor, and compliance responsibilities. However, People Operations teams are beginning to ask for more data from the immigration teams. As we see an increasing importance to invest in creating a delightful employee experience and leveraging people data insights to deliver more business value, HR teams are taking a smarter approach to immigration case processing and reporting.

Read Story